InspirationTuts
  • About
  • Cookie Policy
  • Contact
Wednesday, March 22, 2023
  • 2D
    • All
    • 2D Animation
    • Drawing
    • Graphic Design
    • Painting
    • Storyboarding
    Photoshop vs Affinity Photo | How to Choose the Right One for You?

    Photoshop vs Affinity Photo | How to Choose the Right One for You?

    Best Painting Apps for iPhone and iPad (free included!)

    Best Painting Apps for iPhone and iPad (free included!)

    Photoshop not responding on Mac issue resolved.

    Photoshop Not Responding on Mac? A Guide to Fix the Problem

    Photoshop vs CorelDraw | Which is Better?

    Photoshop vs CorelDraw | Which is Better?

    Flipaclip vs Procreate | Which is the Best? (and why)

    Flipaclip vs Procreate | Which is the Best? (and why)

    Flipaclip Vs Stick Nodes | Which One is Better?

    Flipaclip Vs Stick Nodes | Which One is Better?

    Flipaclip vs Rough Animator | Which One to Choose?

    Flipaclip vs Rough Animator | Which One to Choose?

    Best Photoshop Plugins for Painting

    Best Photoshop Plugins for Painting

    Adobe Photoshop Vs Photoshop Elements | Ultimate Comparison

    Adobe Photoshop Vs Photoshop Elements | Ultimate Comparison

    Trending Tags

    • 2D Software
    • 2D Art Careers
    • 2D Software Comparisons
    • Toon Boom Harmony
    • Open Toonz
  • 3D
    • All
    • 3D Animation
    • Modeling
    • Printing
    • Rendering
    • Texturing
    3ds Max Rendering: is it good? (and how to do it right)

    3ds Max Rendering: is it good? (and how to do it right)

    Overwatch characters from Blizzard Games

    BLIZZARD games: how they’re made and what 3D software they use

    What is UV Mapping & Unwrapping? (full beginners guide)

    What is UV Mapping & Unwrapping? (full beginners guide)

    3Ds Max for VFX work

    3Ds Max for VFX: is it good? (and why you should use it)

    What is Photogrammetry? (and how to do it yourself)

    What is Photogrammetry? (and how to do it yourself)

    The history of 3d animation

    The history of 3D modeling and animation

    How to make a 3d animated short film

    How to Make a 3D Animated Short Film (Quick Breakdown)

    3D modeling types explained

    All 3D Modeling Types | Everything you Need to Know

    Product documentation software

    Create 3D product design manuals online (step-by-step guide)

    Trending Tags

    • 3D Software
    • 3D Software Comparisons
    • 3D Art Careers
    • Blender
    • 3Ds Max
    • 3Ds Max Plugins
    • Blender Addons
    • Blender Courses
  • CAD
    • All
    • ArchViz
    • Interior Design
    Best 2D Architecture Software | Beginner Friendly

    10 Best 2D Architecture Software | Beginner Friendly

    Best BIM Software

    Best BIM Software for Beginners (free included)

    Best Free 2D Architecture Software

    Best Free 2D Architecture Software for Beginners

    Best Game Engines for Architectural Visualization

    Top 5 Game Engines for Architectural Visualization

    Free Online Industrial Design Software

    Free Online Industrial Design Software | Beginner Friendly

    What is Sketchup Used For? | Full Software Review

    What is Sketchup? | Full Software Review & Use Cases

    3Ds Max vs Maya for Architecture | Which one is Better?

    3Ds Max vs Maya for Architecture | Which one is Better?

    Fusion 360 VS FreeCAD | Which is Better?

    Fusion 360 VS FreeCAD | Which is Better?

    Best CAD Software for Furniture

    Best CAD Software for Furniture Design in 2021 | Free Options Included

    Trending Tags

    • CAD Software
    • CAD Software Comparisons
    • AutoCAD
    • Architecture Careers
  • Game Development
  • Motion Graphics
  • Visual Effects
  • Video Editing
  • XR
  • Hardware
No Result
View All Result
  • 2D
    • All
    • 2D Animation
    • Drawing
    • Graphic Design
    • Painting
    • Storyboarding
    Photoshop vs Affinity Photo | How to Choose the Right One for You?

    Photoshop vs Affinity Photo | How to Choose the Right One for You?

    Best Painting Apps for iPhone and iPad (free included!)

    Best Painting Apps for iPhone and iPad (free included!)

    Photoshop not responding on Mac issue resolved.

    Photoshop Not Responding on Mac? A Guide to Fix the Problem

    Photoshop vs CorelDraw | Which is Better?

    Photoshop vs CorelDraw | Which is Better?

    Flipaclip vs Procreate | Which is the Best? (and why)

    Flipaclip vs Procreate | Which is the Best? (and why)

    Flipaclip Vs Stick Nodes | Which One is Better?

    Flipaclip Vs Stick Nodes | Which One is Better?

    Flipaclip vs Rough Animator | Which One to Choose?

    Flipaclip vs Rough Animator | Which One to Choose?

    Best Photoshop Plugins for Painting

    Best Photoshop Plugins for Painting

    Adobe Photoshop Vs Photoshop Elements | Ultimate Comparison

    Adobe Photoshop Vs Photoshop Elements | Ultimate Comparison

    Trending Tags

    • 2D Software
    • 2D Art Careers
    • 2D Software Comparisons
    • Toon Boom Harmony
    • Open Toonz
  • 3D
    • All
    • 3D Animation
    • Modeling
    • Printing
    • Rendering
    • Texturing
    3ds Max Rendering: is it good? (and how to do it right)

    3ds Max Rendering: is it good? (and how to do it right)

    Overwatch characters from Blizzard Games

    BLIZZARD games: how they’re made and what 3D software they use

    What is UV Mapping & Unwrapping? (full beginners guide)

    What is UV Mapping & Unwrapping? (full beginners guide)

    3Ds Max for VFX work

    3Ds Max for VFX: is it good? (and why you should use it)

    What is Photogrammetry? (and how to do it yourself)

    What is Photogrammetry? (and how to do it yourself)

    The history of 3d animation

    The history of 3D modeling and animation

    How to make a 3d animated short film

    How to Make a 3D Animated Short Film (Quick Breakdown)

    3D modeling types explained

    All 3D Modeling Types | Everything you Need to Know

    Product documentation software

    Create 3D product design manuals online (step-by-step guide)

    Trending Tags

    • 3D Software
    • 3D Software Comparisons
    • 3D Art Careers
    • Blender
    • 3Ds Max
    • 3Ds Max Plugins
    • Blender Addons
    • Blender Courses
  • CAD
    • All
    • ArchViz
    • Interior Design
    Best 2D Architecture Software | Beginner Friendly

    10 Best 2D Architecture Software | Beginner Friendly

    Best BIM Software

    Best BIM Software for Beginners (free included)

    Best Free 2D Architecture Software

    Best Free 2D Architecture Software for Beginners

    Best Game Engines for Architectural Visualization

    Top 5 Game Engines for Architectural Visualization

    Free Online Industrial Design Software

    Free Online Industrial Design Software | Beginner Friendly

    What is Sketchup Used For? | Full Software Review

    What is Sketchup? | Full Software Review & Use Cases

    3Ds Max vs Maya for Architecture | Which one is Better?

    3Ds Max vs Maya for Architecture | Which one is Better?

    Fusion 360 VS FreeCAD | Which is Better?

    Fusion 360 VS FreeCAD | Which is Better?

    Best CAD Software for Furniture

    Best CAD Software for Furniture Design in 2021 | Free Options Included

    Trending Tags

    • CAD Software
    • CAD Software Comparisons
    • AutoCAD
    • Architecture Careers
  • Game Development
  • Motion Graphics
  • Visual Effects
  • Video Editing
  • XR
  • Hardware
InspirationTuts
No Result
View All Result
InspirationTuts
No Result
View All Result
Home Articles

Substance Painter VS Mari which is Better?

inspirationTuts by inspirationTuts
July 18, 2021
in Articles, Game Development, Visual Effects
180 13
0
Substance Painter VS Mari which is Better?
145
SHARES
4.8k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Sponsored

A lot of people are trying to find a good program that can help them paint and texture their 3d assets, today.

There are two great pieces of software in this category which are: Substance Painter Vs Mari, they both have pros and cons and can be useful for you depending on the type of work you do.

In this video, we are going to take a look at both of them to let you know which one can suit your needs better.

You can check both software websites’ in the following links:

Substance Painter: https://www.adobe.com/mena_en/products/substance3d-painter.html

Mari: https://www.foundry.com/products/mari

VFX for film & TV

Substance Painter Vs Mari


Mari

When it comes to VFX work for film and television, Mari is the weapon of choice for many artists and studios in this industry because it was created to paint and texture models and characters in film projects with a super high resolution to keep the details visible even with close up shots.

It was developed by Weta Digital for the productions of King Kong and Avatar. And Several years later, the software was acquired by The Foundry.

and it became rapidly popular in some of the largest VFX production studios such as Digital Domain, Framestore, Dneg, and ILM just to name a few.

Mari was used to painting and texture 3d assets in a big portion of VFX heavy movies like the Marvel and DC movies, and many other fantastic films we have seen recently.

Substance Painter

It is also a powerful painting and texturing application that can be used to work on 3d assets for films but I would say it is not going to be as effective as Mari is.

They both have their pros and cons, and we have yet to see how Substance will be able to handle assets with super high UDIM count, and texture resolution at the scale that MARI can.

Also organic and Large environments or anything of that kind can be handled better using Mari.

Sometimes in VFX projects, the 2 programs are used by VFX artists, first substance painter for a quick start to create a base because it is fast and later Mari to paint details.


Game development

For Making video game assets substance painter is industry standard and it is currently the favorite texturing and painting tool for game studios and game artists who work as freelancers or sell game assets for studios and indie developers.

Substance Painter Vs Mari

Substance Painter is relatively new because it has less than a decade being used in the game development industry but it is now an essential part of video game creation pipelines because it is fast, easy to learn and can be used to create very high-quality assets like characters, weapons, game props, and modular environments.

It is now currently used by major video game studios such as naughty dog, Activision, Microsoft, and rockstar games just to name a few.

It has been used to paint and texture assets for this portion of some of the most iconic video games of the last decade such as the last of us part 1 and 2, doom 2016 and doom eternal, days gone, gears of war, and assassin creed video games just to name a few.

On the other hand, Mari is capable of painting and texturing video game assets but it is not as efficient in this industry as a substance painter is.

Mari is not used in video game development that much but it was used on some very good AAA video games such as the order 1886 to create fantastic 3d assets among them the highly detailed weapons of the game.


Ease of use/difficulty

Substance Painter Vs Mari


When it comes to ease of use, I would say that substance painter is considered one of the most straightforward and easy to use texturing and painting applications, it’s quick to pick up because there are only a bunch of basic tools and features to learn before you begin to apply and try things on your own.

I would say that it’s so easy compared to Mari to the extent that it probably makes you lazy when it comes to painting and texturing because you don’t have to understand what is going on behind the scenes most of the time since Substance painter is highly procedural but if you want to work on complex projects you need to put in the effort and have to be talented to get a very good result.

On the other hand, Mari can be considered harder to learn compared to substance painter depending on where you are coming from. For example, if you are a substance painter user trying to learn Mari it is going to be a little bit annoying because suddenly you have to do things that substance used to do for you like super-easy baking and the quick access to smart materials and other stuff.

But if you come from software where you have to set your bake manually and spend several minutes playing around with nodes to get the look you after then Mari will not be as frightening.

Unlike substance painter, Mari is not as procedural meaning you have to paint each layer and channel individually which gives freedom and more control but it can take longer to finish stuff.

Also, Mari has additional things compared to substance painter that you need to learn if you want to be good at that might not be easily learned, but if you become good at using Mari you will have a great advantage.


Materials


Substance Painter is a blessing when it comes to materials because it comes with a good set of materials and smart materials that you can use from the get-go. In addition to having a library of smart masks, alphas, and so on.

If you don’t really like the materials that come with painter you can go to substance share online which is a special platform for substance painter users where you find hundreds of free to use materials, smart materials, masks, and much more.

And if you can’t find what you need there you can use a substance designer which is a software made by the same company as a painter created for artists looking to create their own custom materials which can give an insane degree of freedom and control over the final result.

But I must say that learning and working using Substance Designer can be considered a nightmare compared to a substance painter but if you learn it it is going to be worth it.

On the other hand, in Mari, you can create your material presets library and share them with friends or team members very quickly.


Foundry the developers of Mari added support for thousands of physically-based rendering textures sets with the addition of the material ingest tool.


Also using the node graph you can get any type of result you want to get in terms of materials especially knowing that Mari now is going more in the direction of proceduralism in some aspects of its workflow.

So in terms of materials substance painter is better and faster especially for beginners or for quick assets but Mari is being developed further with every release to help artists get equipped with better materials.


Software stability

Mari can handle very complex scenes with many Udims up to several hundred when working on complex projects.

It is designed to handle huge amounts of data because it was created for the film industry in the first place to be able to create an insanely high resolution of textures compared to what other software could ever come close to because it can handle working with up to 32k textures.

On the other hand, Substance painter does not support working on super high res textures like Mari does since it is primarily used in the game development industry but it can handle large scenes nonetheless but it might take longer to finish certain processes when things get complicated. But in the end, it is also related to your hardware especially the graphics card your have on your computer.

Even though using Substance painter at the beginning of a project is easier and faster achieving a really good end result still often requires a lot of manual work..

Substance Painter Vs Mari

Also some additional things i want to talk about, for example Mari advantage can go beyond the typical texture resolution UDIM tiles aspect which is a vastly superior texture projection technique.

In Painter, the projection is considered average compared to Mari. In Mari, you could save “projections”, mesh deform source in outside soft to be perfectly matching your object in every smallest detail, and then project back again perfectly matching depth, roughness, and so on, and then re-project again and again whatever times you want.

All that procedural approach for textures is cool and can be very efficient indeed but with Mari, there are smart ways to go around problems, you could just find a photo of certain crack, rust, drips, smears or a photo of the whole building facade and project it precisely, It’s sometimes can take less time and the final result can be effective than tweaking non stop all those procedurals you have created in substance painter.


conclusion

Which of these two programs is best suited to your needs will depend on what you plan to do with it. If you need to create high textures on large assets with lots of udims, then Mari is easily the best choice.

If that doesn’t sound like what you need then I suggest starting with substance for the primary reason that it is much cheaper while fulfilling the prerequisite of being very capable, and the second reason that its unique capabilities in terms of procedural texture generation which would potentially save you a lot of time.

and if you decide you need a bit more details for working on super high-resolution textures or if you want to work on VFX projects down the road then you can turn to Mari, you will have invested comparatively little, financially, while gaining knowledge of a program that may still suit many of your needs going forward.

But at the end of the day the day the choice is going to be yours based on your needs and of course bases on what the software can offer you as we mentioned in this video.

Previous Post

Blender for 2D Animation | Is it as awesome as 3D?

Next Post

is Blende Good for Sculpting?

inspirationTuts

inspirationTuts

Next Post
is Blende Good for Sculpting?

is Blende Good for Sculpting?

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Most Discussed

  • 4 Best 3D Software For Character Creation | Beginner Friendly!

    4 Best 3D Software For Character Creation | Beginner Friendly!

    181 shares
    Share 72 Tweet 45
  • Top Vector Apps for Android | Including Free!

    262 shares
    Share 105 Tweet 66
  • If you can’t learn Blender | Motivation for 3D artists

    131 shares
    Share 52 Tweet 33
  • Best Maya Modeling Plugins (free included!)

    155 shares
    Share 62 Tweet 39
  • Top 41 Free Addons for Blender (limited time!)

    447 shares
    Share 178 Tweet 112
Sponsored
InspirationTuts

© 2022 InspirationTuts - All Rights Reserved

Useful Links

  • About
  • Cookie Policy
  • Contact

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • 2D
  • 3D
  • CAD
  • Game Development
  • Motion Graphics
  • Visual Effects
  • Video Editing
  • XR
  • Hardware

© 2022 InspirationTuts - All Rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In